Would you all rather have a standard nether or separate nether islands? Both options would be accessible from a nether portal on your island. Here are the differences: Nether Islands: Have a separate island in the nether world that would server as essentially a second island to you. No major difference aside from nether theme to the island, starter island composed of nether items, and ability to grow glowstone trees. This island would most likely be smaller than your main island but would server as a separate building space. No major effect on the economy. Nether: Full access to the nether at your disposal from a portal on your island. If this was implemented, you'd be able to harvest and sell nether items for most likely relatively low prices. Flight would be disabled. You'd be able to make a small protection claim in the nether to setup base. There's a pretty big difference between the two, but we can't do both. If you have a preference, let us know by voting in the poll and explain why you chose your side in a comment so we can get a better idea of where you all stand.